Debate Tactics Analysis

Fallacy Alert: Argument by Tangent Mechanism

Learn how to call out bullshit when they argue by tangential supporting constructs.

Johnny Silvercloud
AfroSapiophile
Published in
6 min readMay 11, 2022

--

White male Trump supporter in D.C. during Trump’s Inauguration period. He probably makes bitchass arguments protecting vague-ass mechanisms. I know he does. Look at him! 20 Jan 2017 | Photo Credit: Johnny Silvercloud

Dumbass Argument Styles Deconstructed

Ever seen an argument like this?

“I support State’s rights!”

“I support {insert person’s} right, to free speech!” (after saying something politically horrible)

When someone makes an argument like this, do you ever feel, somewhat pissed, as if that person is using acute pick-pocketing skills and ran off with your wallet and wristwatch? You just know something’s wrong but you can’t explain it, or chase after them? Perhaps you get that same feeling as when someone blatantly lies in your face.

You know the feeling.

You know there’s something up, but you don’t have the vocabulary to call them out. You squint your eyes, maybe look to the left or right, and you don’t know what to say.

Something’s logically, rationally wrong and you can’t put your finger on it.

--

--

Johnny Silvercloud
AfroSapiophile

20 yr U.S. Army vet turned analytical street photographer who talks about power, protest, and politics. Do not defend racism or sexism when I’m in the room.